Ideology and Pragmatism in Islamic Republic of Iran’s Foreign Policy: A Case Study of the Rouhani Administration

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD student, Department of Political Science, Chalous Branch, Islamic Azad University, Chalous, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, Chalous Branch, Islamic Azad University, Chalous, Iran.

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science, Chalous Branch, Islamic Azad University, Chalous, Iran.

Abstract

Foreign policy is the strategy designed by a state’s policy makers in relation to interactions with other states and international actors to achieve national objectives and safeguard national interests. An in-depth look into the Islamic Republic of Iran’s foreign policy indicates a set of ideological norms, principles, and objectives as well as a pragmatic approach, manifested in the last decades. Accepting the current realities in the world, a pragmatic foreign policy pursues maximum utilization of opportunities with regard to national interests of a given state. This study aimed to determine the role of ideology and pragmatism in Iran’s foreign policy during Hassan Rouhani’s presidency. It also attempted to establish which one of these factors was more essential and carried more weight. Accordingly, this was a historical-analytical study relying on library research. The results demonstrated that the rough core of Iran’s foreign policy based on ideological preference was the most important factor in determining Iran’s foreign strategies and policies under the Rouhani administration. Influenced by its sublime signifier, Rouhani’s government leaned towards moderation; while upholding an Islamic discourse whose elements were based on the principles and values of the Islamic Revolution, the Rouhani administration used its rationalistic and balanced approach, based on consequentialism, to deconstruct the structure of the international system.
Extended abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
  In today’s complex international relations, adopting a rational approach is inevitable to gain the most advantages from the least capacities, critical situations, and the slightest diplomatic openings. Iran’s eleventh and twelfth governments under Hassan Rouhani were formed based on this view. The purpose of this study was determining the central factors regarding ideology and pragmatism in Islamic Republic of Iran’s foreign policy. Accordingly, the share of ideology and pragmatism and their level of essentiality in Iran’s foreign policy were specified during Hassan Rouhani’s two terms in office. The main hypothesis was that Iran’s foreign policy during Rouhani’s presidency took a pragmatic turn in many cases; however, its core remained intact and ideologically-driven.
 
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
There is no available consensus on a single fitting conceptual or theoretical framework for studying and analyzing the Islamic Republic of Iran’s foreign policy. This results from the relationship between an international relations theory and the Islamic Republic’s identity and foreign policy. It is crucial to note that using conceptual frameworks based on international relations theories to analyze Iran’s foreign policy involves many theoretical limitations. The first limitation rises from the nature of international relations theories that are propounded to explain and preserve the historical and cultural international order. The Islamic nature of Iran’s regime is another limitation, which challenges selecting a fitting conceptual framework for analyzing its foreign policy. Therefore, the Islamic nature of the 1979 revolution in Iran and the ideology legitimizing its resultant political system restrict the application of revolutionary foreign policy theories. However, this does not justify the development of a particular theory for analyzing Iran’s foreign policy.
 
3- METHODOLOGY
  This historical-analytical study was based on library research. Accordingly, the role of ideology and pragmatism in Iran’s foreign policy during the Rouhani administration was examined using discourse analysis.
 
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
  Ideology in the foreign policy of Iran’s eleventh and twelfth governments
Islamism is the dominant ideology of the Islamic Republic of Iran; nonetheless, Rouhani attempted to present milder interpretations with regard to ideological issues in his discourse of moderation. In addition to establishing a balance between realistic and idealistic objectives, this approach avoided exaggeration and ideologization of issues, highlighting Iran’s national interests. This is because moderate ideologism requires a balance between realism and idealism or national and ideological interests of Iran.
Pragmatism in the foreign policy of Iran’s eleventh and twelfth governments
When Rouhani came to power in 2013, a new approach was adopted in Iran’s foreign policy, prioritizing ties with neighbors and countries in the region. The Rouhani administration pursued its prized order under a strategy based on constructive interaction and de-escalation of tensions. The cardinal characteristics of Rouhani’s foreign policy included de-escalating tensions, trust-building, rationalism in foreign policy, saving face and improving Iran’s position in the world, active diplomacy, balanced and improved relations, particularly with Iran’s neighbors.
 
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
  The predominant discourse of the eleventh and twelfth governments of Iran encompassed a balance of idealism and realism. In conjunction with accepting its idealistic and deconstructive mission, the Rouhani administration was observant of the requirements and current frameworks of the international system. During these two terms, Iran’s foreign policy was a combination of pragmatic and ideological approaches, each prioritized at different times according to the degree they secured Iran’s national interests. Nevertheless, the unshakable principle in Iran’s foreign policy remained its ideological aspect, which proved to be more essential. Pragmatism in Iran’s foreign policy can be traced to limitations in sources of national power and restrictions imposed by the international system.

Keywords


 
Brahmbhatt, M, et. al. (1996). “India in the global economy”, World Bank Policy Research, Working Paper.
 Bhat, T (2011). “Structural changes in India’s foreign trade”, Available at: http://isidev.
nic.in/pdf/ICSSR_TPB.pdf (Accessed on: 2012, 17 September).
 Campbell, P. L. (2011). Peirce, pragmatism, and the right way of thinking. Sandia National Laboratories: Albuquerque.
 Dehghani Firouzabadi, S.J (2015). "Moderationism Discourse in the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran", Foreign Policy Quarterly, Volume 28, Issue 1. Pages 1 – 34. [In Persian]
 Daman Pak Jami, M (2019). "Economic Diplomatic Development of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Reviewing the Achievements of the Past Four Decehrades and the Challenges Ahead", Foreign Policy Quarterly, Volume 32, Issue 4. Pages 29-30. [In Persian]
 Dehghani Firouzabadi, S.J (2015). The discourse cycle in the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran: from Bazargan state to the Rouhani state, Tehran: Mokhatab [In Persian]
Dehghani Firouzabadi, S.J and Soleimani Pourlak, F (2022). Iran’s Foreign Policy and International Norm, Tehran: Institution for Political and International Studies [In Persian]
 Deshiri, M.R (2014) "Nuclear agreement and the fabrication of Iran's new identity in international public opinion", International Relations Research Quarterly, Volume 1, Issue 16. Pages 26-29. [In Persian]
 Ebrahimi, Sh (2010), a constructive study of the role of ideology in Iran's foreign policy and its connection with realism and idealism, International Quarterly of Foreign Relations, Volume 1, Issue 4. Pages 122-125. [In Persian]
 Frustenberg, K (7 Aug 2013). “Iran's New President: Foreign Policy Challenges for Rohani”, Institue of Peace and Conflict Studies, 4073, in http://www.ipcs.org/comm_select.php?articleNo=4073.
 France Diplomatie (31 Jan 2019). “Joint statement on the creation of INSTEX” in: https://www.diplomatie.gouv. fr/en/countryfiles/iran/events /article/joint-statement-on-the-creation-of-instex-thespecial-purpose-vehicle-aimed-at.
Hajiyusefi, A.M and Mohammadian, M (2016). "Historical sociology and iranian foreign policy: Athepretical Framework “, global policy Quartely, volume 5, Issue4, pages 73-74. [In Persian]
 Herszenhorn, D (8/6/2018). “Europe vows to fight for Iran deal as US renews sanctions”, in: https://www.politico.eu/article/ federicamogherini-europe-vows-to-fight-for-iran-deal-as-us-donald-trumprenews-sanctions
 Hasanpour, J (2016). "Theoretical explanation of the challenges of national interests in the foreign policy approach of the Islamic Republic of Iran: the ideal-reality puzzle", International Relations Research Quarterly, Volume 1, Issue 16. Pages 178-179. [In Persian]
 Karimi, Gh. R (2014). "Examination of the moderation-oriented discourse of the 11th government based on idealistic realism", moderate foreign policy conference, Tehran: Office of Political and International Studies, March 15, extraction date: 6/12/1400, www. profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1040817. [In Persian]
 Karlin, R, Anna and Yuval peres (2016) “Game Theory, Alive”, in: https://homes. cs. washington .edu/ karlin/GameTheoryBook.pdf.
 Khalili, R (2015). "The 11th presidential election and the prospect of the nuclear program of the Islamic Republic of Iran", Strategic Studies Quarterly, Volume 17, Issue 1. Pages 143-145. [In Persian]
 Khosravi Bab Anari, M.T (2010). "The foreign policy approach of the 11th government towards the order and security of the Middle East region", International Relations Studies Quarterly, Volume 10, Issue 39.Pages 49-50. [In Persian]
 Mogherini, F (August 16, 2017). Tabnak site, extraction date: 12/6/1400, http://www.tabnak.ir/fa/news/823105
 Motaghi, M.A and Tabatabai Panah, S.A (2021). Analysis of the impact of elements of Rouhani government's moderation discourse on the relations between the Islamic Republic of Iran and the European Union, Scientific Quarterly of International Relations Studies, Volume 13, Issue 50. Pages 194-195. [In Persian]
 Mogherini, F (4/7/2019). "Press interview on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly", Khabar Network, extraction date: 12/6/1400, http://www. irinn.ir /fa/news/628666/
 Motahari, M, (1386). Insan Wayman, Tehran: Sadra. [In Persian]
 Mohaghegh Nia, H and Rezakhani, J; Davtalab Vazifeh M.R; Rezvanpour, R (2019). Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran during Rouhani's Presidency in the 11th Administration, Political and International Research Quarterly, Volume 9, Issue 34. Pages 241-243. [In Persian]
 Mohammadnia, M (2016). "Comparative study of the foreign policy of fundamentalist and moderate governments", Political Research Quarterly, Volume 2, Issue 1. Pages 194-195. [In Persian]
 Mirali, H and Naveedinia, F (1401). review of the Rouhani government's policy and performance on the nuclear issue with an emphasis on the JCPOA debate, Political and International Research Quarterly, Volume 13, Issue 50. Pages 60-65. [In Persian]
 Mahmoudi Kia, M and Dehshiri M.R (2019). the ratio of pragmatism and ideology in Iran's foreign policy; A strategic or tactical approach? Strategic Policy Research Quarterly, Volume 9, Issue 32. Pages 18-21. [In Persian]
 Milani, M (2013). Rouhani’s Foreign Policy: How to Work with Iran’s Pragmatic New President, in: [In Persian]  https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/iran/2013-06-25/rouhanis-foreign-policy
 Osiewicz, P (2019). Ideologizing and Fundamentalism in Iranian Foreign Policy under the Hassan Rouhani Presidency, in: https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/JEMEAA/Journals/Volume-01_Issue-2/JEMEAA_01_2_Osiewicz.pdf
 Rouhani, H (11/11/2016). Tasnim news agency, extraction date: 6/24/1400. https://www.tasnimnews.com/fa/news/ [In Persian]
 Rouhani, H (6/19/2014). IRNA news agency, extraction date: 6/24/2022. http://www.irna.ir/fa/News/81290015 [In Persian]
 Rouhani, H (12/4/2014). The world of economics, extraction date: 24/6/1400, /https://donya-e-eqtesad.com1791199 [In Persian]
 Rouhani, H (8/4/2014). "Speech at the Media Horizon Conference", Analytical News Database of Chogh, extraction date: 6/23/1400, http://www.entekhab.ir/fa/news/119133/ [In Persian]
 Rezaei, A.R and Torabi, Q (2014). Hassan Rouhani's foreign policy, constructive interaction in the framework of the development-oriented government, International Political Research Quarterly, Volume 5, Issue 15. Pages 131-152. [In Persian]
 Sabouri, Z (2020). validation of the effectiveness of the moderate approach in Iran's foreign policy and the regional strategies of the 12th government, International Relations Research Quarterly, No. 3 [In Persian]
 Sabouri, Z and Salehian, T (2018). Strategic review of the economic diplomacy of the Islamic Republic of Iran, a case study: the 11th and 12th governments, International Relations Quarterly, Volume 7, Issue 24.pages141-146. [In Persian]
 Shanahan, R (2015). Iranian foreign policy under Rouhani, in: https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/188299/iranian-foreign-policy-under-rouhani.pdf
 Soltani Gardframarzi, M and Ashrafi, A; Bakshaish Ardestani, A; Safaroudi, S (2020), Comparison of Hassan Rouhani's Nuclear Discourse and Islamic Revolution Discourse, Political Science Quarterly, Volume 14, Issue 49. Pages 130-131. [In Persian]
 Sarmi, M.R and Rezaei, A.R; Turabi, Q (2022). The consequences of the Rouhani government's foreign policy on the international interactions of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Scientific Quarterly of International Relations Studies, Volume 14, Issue 53. Pages 165-166. [In Persian]
 Welayati, A. R and Dehghani Firouzabadi, S. J; Shakerkhoei, E; Alipour, J (2023), The role of religious discourse in the foreign policy sub-discourse of the moderate government, Political and International Research Quarterly, Volume 13. Issue 50, Pages 145-149. [In Persian]
 Zarif, M.J (2018). "The foreign policy approach and program of the twelfth government", extraction date: 5/15/2022. [In Persian]
Zarif, M.J (2016). "The foreign policy approach and program of the twelfth government", extraction date: 5/15/1400, www.mfa.gov.ir [In Persian]