نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
نویسندگان
1 استادیار روابط بین الملل، گروه علوم سیاسی ، دانشگاه اصفهان، اصفهان، ایران.
2 کارشناسی ارشد روابط بین الملل، گروه علوم سیاسی، دانشگاه اصفهان، اصفهان، ایران.
چکیده
کلیدواژهها
عنوان مقاله [English]
نویسندگان [English]
Energy is a critical requirement for all developed countries in the world today. Emerging powers like India require energy to sustain their development. Therefore, the Persian Gulf region, abundant in oil and gas, has become a global hotspot. The central research question of this proposal is how India, a key player in the energy game, can balance stability and maintain its status quo among its many energy partners in the Persian Gulf. This proposal is grounded in the idea of neorealism and its components. It posits that India, in order to continue and survive as an emerging power, has strategically made economic relations with the Persian Gulf region one of the main principles of its diplomacy. The research method is qualitative-descriptive, and the aim is to delve into how India can balance stability and maintain its current position among the different energy partners in the Persian Gulf. The findings suggest that India is not currently pursuing hegemonic power in the Persian Gulf but is instead looking for a more efficient and cost-effective development trajectory for itself.
Introduction
Energy, especially oil and gas, plays a crucial role in today's industrial age. Forecasts indicate that energy consumption will continue to grow until 2030. India, the seventh-largest country with the fourth-largest economy, is rapidly emerging as an economic powerhouse with significant hydrocarbon resources. India has extensive energy ties with Persian Gulf countries such as Saudi Arabia, Iran, and the United Arab Emirates. Given its strategic location near the Persian Gulf, India closely monitors sensitive areas like Chabahar and the Strait of Hormuz. The current research question revolves around how India can maintain stability and manage its relationships with various energy partners in the Persian Gulf. This question will be addressed during the research process.
Theoretical Framework
The neorealist theory asserts that the government is the primary actor in international relations. In an authoritarian international system, conflict over security and power is a persistent reality. This theory is particularly relevant to the Persian Gulf, which has become a hotbed of conflict between powers like China and India. Security is a key component of this theory, suggesting that the Persian Gulf region is an anarchic environment in terms of security. According to neorealism, for a country to become a great power, it needs various components such as a large population, significant size, an active democracy, and economic strength. These elements help the country achieve its goals. In the case of India, regional forces, asymmetric forces like the Houthis, and rival powers such as China pose threats to the security of the Persian Gulf region. Therefore, India is committed to maintaining the security and stability of this region and should continue its peaceful relations with the area. Neorealism also discusses great powers, military capabilities, and combined powers, which include political, military, and economic strength. India also requires this region's oil and gas resources to enhance its combined power. However, despite the presence of great powers like the US, China, and Russia, it cannot be claimed that India is seeking to become a hegemonic power. Nevertheless, India has expanded its sphere of influence from South Asia to the Indo-Pacific in recent years.
3. Methodology
The research is a qualitative-descriptive study, with data collected from documents and library sources. It utilizes scientific research with neorealistic components to explain India's role in the Persian Gulf.
Results and Discussion
The Persian Gulf is a region abundant in fossil energy and holds significant commercial and transit potential. This has made it a focal point for major global powers, particularly emerging ones. The coastlines of Makran and the Chabahar port are particularly noteworthy. India is engaged in economic competition with its rival, China, and its political rival, Pakistan, to leverage the capabilities of the Chabahar port. Similarly, China has initiated the Gwadar port project with Pakistan, which has been partially completed. However, Iran and India have faced challenges in achieving financial and political success in developing the Chabahar port.
5. Conclusion
India aims to actively strengthen its ties with the Persian Gulf region, particularly with Saudi Arabia, Iran, and the United Arab Emirates. This involves various economic, political, and psychological relations, such as collaboration with refinery entrepreneurs, trade in foreign goods, and the participation of Arab forces in the Quad meeting. Additionally, India is focused on energy production cooperation with Iran and has ambitious plans to develop the Chabahar port. Through investments in the Chabahar port, India seeks to establish shorter energy production routes and expand its influence in regional markets. India has three options: first, utilizing domestic reserves by addressing legal issues in the upstream sector and investing within and outside the country. The second option is importing gas through LNG, with contracts signed with Oman and Qatar. The third option is establishing pipelines, which would involve high construction costs and various technical, financial, and political challenges
کلیدواژهها [English]
Amiri, A. Haghighi, A.M and Zarei, G (2019). The political-economic consequences of the geopolitical management of the Strait of Hormuz in Iran's foreign policy on the security of the Persian Gulf. Iranian Political Sociology Quarterly, Volume 3, Issue 3. pages 932-951. (In Persian)
Bagheri, M and Basiri, M.A (2014). Examining the relationship between Lebanon's Hezbollah and the national security of the Islamic Republic from the perspective of constructivism and neo-realism. Quarterly Journal of Islamic Revolution Studies, Volume 12, Issue 4. pages 27-49. (In Persian)
Baloch, A and Lotfi, H (2017). A macro perspective on space planning and organization in Makran region (case study: Chabahar). Geography Quarterly, Volume 8, Issue 4. pages 61-90. (In Persian)
Barati, A, Ahmadi, S.A and Zarei, B (2021). Explanation of the defense-security challenges of sea-oriented development on the regional and international scale of Makran coasts from the point of view of political geography. Defense Strategy Scientific Quarterly, Volume 74, Issue 19. pages 55-87. (In Persian)
Barzegarzadeh Zarandi, M and Ahmadi, S.A (2017). Levels of cooperation, competition and conflict in geopolitical and geoeconomic relations between Iran and India. Foreign Relations Quarterly, Volume 39, Issue 19. pages 37-66. (In Persian)
Corbeau, A.S (2010). Natural Gas in India. International Energy Agency Working Paper. Issue No. Accessed on 28/01/2023, Available Online at: https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/9de2aa4f-1b6e-4189-9f58-88a670feff25/natural_gas_india_2010.pdf.
Daneshnia, F (2014). The application of game theory and neoliberal institutionalism in the analysis of the behavior of the main OPEC gas players. Political Science Quarterly, Volume 8, Issue 1. pages 172-143. (In Persian)
Dehghani Firouzabadi, S.J and Izadi, J (2017). The global perspective of oil and gas supply and demand and Iran's geostrategic position. International Relations Research Quarterly, Volume 8, Issue 1. pages 245-280. (In Persian)
Doherty, J and Faltzgraf, R (2011). Conflicting Theories in International Relations (5th edition). Bozurgi, V. Tehran: Qoms Publication. (In Persian)
Jafari, A.A and Khavosh, A (2015). Investigating political-strategic and geopolitical dimensions of the Persian Gulf, case study: Strait of Hormuz. Persian Gulf National Conference on Academic Jihad, Volum 11, Issue No. pages 486-475. (In Persian)
Jafari, S.A; Yazdani, E and Basiri, M.A (2017). Explaining the reproduction of the conflict between the Islamic Republic and the United States in Southwest Asia in the post-Jarq era; Return to neorealism. International Political Research Quarterly, Volume 34, Issue 10. pages 1-28. (In Persian)
Karimipour, Y; Mojtahedzadeh, P and Zarghami, I (2017). Naval strategy and national power (a new approach to naval strategy). Strategic Knowledge Interdisciplinary Studies Quarterly, Volume 3, Issue 8. pages 189-212. (In Persian)
Keypour, J and Izadi, J (2010). Energy diplomacy and the need to use it to secure Iran's national interests in the world. Foreign Relations Quarterly, Volume 4, Issue 1. pages 139-162. (In Persian)
Khazaei, A; Mojtabinia, M.H and Amiri, K (2022). The effect of sustainable. development of Makran coast on the maritime power of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Military Sciences and Techniques Quarterly, Volume 62, Issue 18. pages 217-241. (In Persian)
Kolaee, E and Vaezi, T (2011). The evolution of foreign policy and economic development of India. Foreign Relations Quarterly, Volume 4, Issue 1. pages247-274. (In Persian)
Lekzi, M and Athari, A (2022). The role of the coasts of Makran in advancing the regional power of the Islamic Republic of Iran. J.A. Iran Strategic Environmental Quarterly, Volume 6, Issue 1. pages 163-190. (In Persian)
Lotfi, H (2021). Investigating the role of Makran region in the security of the Persian Gulf. Geographic Information Quarterly, Volume 117, Issue 30. pages 267-280. (In Persian).
Malakutian, M and Aghdaei, S.H (2012). The role and position of natural gas in India's energy policy: examining the available options for supplying natural gas needed by India. Politics Quarterly, Volume 43, Issue 2. pages 121-135. (In Persian).
Md.Muddassir, Q (2022). India and the Persian Gulf: Bilateralism, Regional Security and the China Factor. Security and Development Policy Quarterly, Volume 10, Issue 5. Page 1-11.
Mirzajani, M and Lotfi, H (2016). The role and influence of the Persian Gulf Cooperation Council and the Makran region in the international economy and its strategic impact on Iran by presenting a strategic model in economic and political development. Geography Quarterly, Volume 8, Quarterly 1. pages 57-91. (In Persian)
Mohammadi, H.R and Ahmadi, I (2017). Equilibrium in India's geopolitical systems (with emphasis on the role and position of Iran's Chabahar port). Earth Science Research Quarterly, Volume 33, Issue 9. pages 46-65. (In Persian)
Mohammadkhani, A (2009). Explaining the approach of neo-realism in international relations. Political Studies Quarterly, Volume 3, Issue 1. pages 83-100. (In Persian)
Mu’tazedrad, A (2018). Developments of global power, India and its approach to West Asia. International Relations Research Quarterly, Volume 35, Issue 9. Pages 205-222. (In Persian)
Norouzizadeh, F; Guderzi, M and Masoudnia, H (2021). The role of geopolitics and geoeconomics of transit energy (oil and gas) of the Persian Gulf in advancing the regional policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Geopolitics Quarterly, Volume 18, Issue 3. Pages 228-255. (In Persian).
Omidi, A and Pourali, I (2014). India's energy security strategy until 2035 and the position of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Energy Economics Studies Quarterly, Volume 45, Issue 10. Pages 1-28. (In Persian).
Pethiyagoda, K (2018). India's Pursuit of Strategic and Economic Interests in Iran. Brookings Doha Center Analysis Paper. Issue No. Pages 1-35. Accessed on 13/11/2022, Available Online at: https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/Indias-Pursuit-of-Strategic-and-Economic-Interests-in-Iran.pdf
RahimiRoshan, H., et al (2022). Evolution of the concept of security in international relations: from structural neo-realism until now. International Politics Quarterly, Volum 2, Issue 1. Pages 9-29.
Rumley Chris, M.K, Allison Ball, R.C (2007). natural gas in india: prospects for LNG imports, abare research report. Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics. Issue No. Pages 3-46. Accessed on: 24/10/2022 Available Online at: http://adl.brs.gov.au/data/warehouse/pe_abare99001415/rr07.23_india_natural_gas.indd.pdf
Shayan, F. (2017). Security in the Persian Gulf Region. London: Palgrave McMillan.
Shayan, F. (2023). Gas-Troika in the European Gas Market: Russia, Iran and Qatar. Boston: De Gruyter.
Singh, M. (2020). India-Persian Gulf Relations: From Transactional to Strategic Partnerships. Energy Quarterly, Volume 5, Issue 3. Pages 157-173. Accessed on: 24/10/2022, Available Online at: https://media.neliti.com/media/publications/327309-india-persian-gulf-relations-from-transa-19e6bcd5.pdf.
Soltani, F; Zarghami, E and Javedani Moghadaam, M (2022). Strategic analysis of maritime power equations in the Indo-Pacific region with emphasis on Quad and Akos grouping. Political Geography Quarterly, Volume 8, Issue 2. Pages 84-113. (In Persia)
SoltaniNejad, M (2015). Iran-India Relations: An Analysis of an Unfinished Strategic Partnership. Foreign Relations Quarterly, Volume 8, Issue 2. Pages 115-141. (In Persian)
Taheri, E (2023), Geopolitics and effects of strategic competition between Iran and Pakistan in Afghanistan (2001-2021), World Politics Quarterly, Volume 12, Issue 3. Pages 113-134. (In Persian)
Tektam, M and Elahi, H (2012). The position of Tiss port in the trade of spices and sugarcane. Jurisprudence and Civilization History of Islamic Nations Quarterly, Volume 35, Issue 9. pages 109-130. )In Persian)
Temple, D (2007). The Iran-Pakistan-India Pipeline: The Interaction of Energy
and Politics. Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies INDIA: New Delhi, Issue No. Pages 1-40. Accessed on 7/01/2023, Available Online at: https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/55133/IPCS-ResearchPaper8-David.pdf.
U.S. Energy Information Administration, International Energy Statistics, 2014
TishehYar, M (2019). Investigating the process of political development of the state in Indian society. Law and Politics Quarterly, Volum 2, Issue 1. Pages 9-29. (In Persian).
)